I have been really struck by some of the rhetoric I have read surrounding the Israeli air strikes of Gaza. The words have been harsh, careless, and cold. Lee thoughtfully comments on this conflict, and on the editorializing that occurs every time the tensions flare up. He also invokes the idea of Just War Theory and its insistence on a notion of proportionality of action. While I think proportionality is of utmost importance in discussing this – and all – military actions. I clearly do not think this is a proportional response. However, I would like to mention one thing Lee did not in his post, which is the issue of non-combatants. For Christian Just War Theory, especially as proposed by St. Thomas Aquinas, a major issue to be dealt with was casualties of non-combatants.
Thomas went to great lengths to defend the lives of those who were not directly involved in military conflict. Thomas was clear that even accidental deaths were completely unacceptable, as noncombatants do not share in the culpability of aggressors, even if aggressors are the leaders of the noncombatants.
So I wonder what St. Thomas would say about these images:


The little boy above is about the same size as my youngest son. What must it be like as a parent to hold your child in the midst of the mortar attack? What must it be like to be unable to protect them?
It amazes me that we want to talk politics while mothers are having to bury their toddlers.
So please, if you must comment, don’t say anything that you wouldn’t say in front of the parents of a wounded or dead child from this conflict.
Posted by Robb (LP)
Posted by Robb (LP)